Fior Research

Service

Critical Friend

Independent, ongoing advice through fieldwork, analysis, and drafting, so that issues are raised while they can still be addressed.

The problem

Many of the problems that surface in pre-publication review begin while the research is under way

Many of the problems that surface in pre-publication review begin while the research is under way: data collection that departs from the agreed design, emerging findings interpreted beyond what the data can support, or pressure to present results in a particular way. By the time a draft reaches review, some of these can no longer be corrected, only acknowledged as limitations.

The service

Independent challenge as the work develops

A critical friend is an experienced researcher from outside the team who offers honest, independent challenge over the course of a project. I work with research, evaluation, and MEL teams through fieldwork, analysis, interpretation, and drafting, reviewing work as it develops and raising concerns early enough for them to be addressed.

Where I have acted as critical friend on a project, a later review of its outputs by me is not fully independent. See how I manage independence and conflicts of interest.

What it involves

  • Regular meetings with the research lead or team, on a schedule agreed at the start.
  • Feedback on data collection tools, analysis frameworks, and emerging findings.
  • Checking that findings are supported by the data and not over-interpreted.
  • Advice on ethical issues arising during fieldwork, unexpected findings, or pressure from stakeholders to present results in a particular way.
  • Participation in reference groups, steering committees, or advisory panels.

Rates run on a sliding scale designed to make high-quality research support accessible across different budgets.

More on how we work together

This is the right service when a project is under way and the team would value independent challenge as it develops, when a local or national organisation is taking on research responsibilities through localisation and direct donor funding, when a commissioner wants independent advice alongside research or an evaluation it has commissioned, or when a multi-year programme has a learning agenda.

Other services

How to get started

Start with a scoping conversation

A short, no-obligation conversation to understand your context and what success would look like. You then receive a fixed-fee quote and an estimated turnaround time.