Service
Output Quality Review
An independent, pre-publication check on whether a specific output meets the requirements of its audience.
The problem
Research reaches its audience with no independent check
Policy research institutes, think tanks, and NGOs produce a great deal of research that goes directly to donors, boards, and the public, and many of these organisations lack the capacity for adequate quality assurance. Unlike academic publishing, which relies on peer review, most commissioned research and evaluation has no independent check on whether the methodology supports the claims, the evidence supports the conclusions, or the writing communicates clearly to its intended audiences.
The volume of research is rising, and much of it is now AI-assisted. The judgement needed to assess it has not kept pace: whether a methodology supports the claims built on it, whether evidence has been over-interpreted, and whether findings will survive scrutiny. That assessment depends on domain expertise and professional accountability.
Weak research is costly: flawed findings inform policy decisions, organisations face reputational damage when methodological shortcomings are exposed, the time given by research participants is not put to best use, and donors lose confidence in the evidence base for their investments. Most of these costs can be prevented by independent review before publication.
The service
An expert judgement of credibility
Output Quality Review is a substantive, pre-publication assessment of a specific output's credibility and integrity. It goes well beyond copy-editing or proofreading, giving you an expert judgement on the research before it reaches the people it is meant to convince.
What is assessed
Reviews assess up to five dimensions
| Dimension | What is assessed |
|---|---|
| Methodological soundness | Is the research design appropriate for the questions asked? Are data collection methods rigorous? Are analytical approaches applied correctly? Are limitations acknowledged honestly? |
| Evidentiary support | Do the findings follow from the data presented? Are claims proportionate to the evidence? Are alternative explanations considered? Is attribution handled carefully? |
| Alignment with objectives | Does the research answer the questions it set out to address? Are the conclusions relevant to the stated purpose? Does the work deliver what the commissioning terms of reference required? |
| Clarity for audiences | Is the writing accessible to the intended readers, whether donors, policymakers, practitioners, or the public? Are technical concepts explained without oversimplification? Is the structure logical? |
| Research standards and methods | Is research quality standardised across multiple outputs so consistency does not depend on who produces each piece? |
What you receive
A structured assessment, with priorities ranked
Each review produces a structured assessment with specific, actionable recommendations: an overall judgement, a section-by-section assessment, and a summary of priority revisions ranked by importance. Where useful, I also provide a follow-up review of the revised version to confirm that issues have been addressed.
Most research quality problems get tackled one output at a time. But where research spans teams, partners, and funders, the same issues recur: inconsistent methods, unclear data handling, findings that cannot be traced to their source, and standards renegotiated with every new project. Reviewing individual outputs catches these late and repeatedly. A portfolio-level assessment looks across a range of outputs, teams, and partners, identifying where standards diverge and defining the standards that would bring consistency. Reviews can therefore be commissioned individually or through a standing retainer covering all outputs before publication, with priority scheduling and a reduced rate.
Rates run on a sliding scale designed to make high-quality research support accessible across different budgets.
More on how we work togetherThe process begins with a brief scoping conversation to understand the material, your timeline, and the level of review required. I then provide a fixed-fee quote and an estimated turnaround time.
Related blog posts
- Fluent but unfounded? AI and the analysis behind humanitarian research
AI tools increasingly sort, summarise, and select the words of people affected by crises before anyone writes a report. Why that matters for research integrity, and what to ask of any report that used them.
- The peer review gap: why so much humanitarian evidence goes unchecked
Much humanitarian and development research is never independently checked before it shapes decisions. Why that gap matters, and what review can offer.
Other services
- Research Design Support
Advice at the inception stage so that gaps, over-ambitious scope, or a mismatch between questions and methods are caught early.
- Critical Friend
Independent, ongoing advice through fieldwork, analysis, and drafting, so that issues are raised while they can still be addressed.
- Commissioned Research
Primary research and evaluations designed, conducted, and written to the same standards of methodology, evidence, and clarity that I apply in quality review.
- Capacity Strengthening and Training
Training, coaching, and mentoring for teams taking on research, built around their live projects.
- Data Governance and Stewardship
Data governance that people follow in practice.
- Strategy Development
Organisational strategy and policy for research.
How to get started
Start with a scoping conversation
A short, no-obligation conversation to understand your context and what success would look like. You then receive a fixed-fee quote and an estimated turnaround time.